Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Richard Bedingfield's avatar

I watched the BBC news report on this last night but it left me very unsatisfied. It illustrates just how easy it is to make a graph seem to prove anything one wishes to peddle. Any use of GDP is bound to mislead because it is averaged to include rising rents and consequent phantom capital gains investors use to measure wealth. Showing a flat line projection for the impact of welfare or the opposite of rising proportionate cost is bound to deceive the viewer. Showing comparative graphs claiming to illustrate rising or falling wealth of a population standard of living is also very questionable. We are not measuring the impact of inflation correctly. When I married in 1970 and bought a new house for £3,450 on maximum earning to mortgage ratio limits , it is impossible to say I would be better off now because I would have to pay £500,000 for the same house on the same earnings to mortgage ratio. I do not believe our current statistical analysis fully takes that impact into account. The problem seems to be that we have forgotten that land value should be taxed properly so that our planning control system does not make us unproductively plough our wealth into land value. That is not true wealth assembly.

Paul Morrison's avatar

Thanks a really helpful clear analysis.

The narative that the number of out of work claimants is increasing fast and this is leading to massive increases in spending is developing virtually unchallenged. It is a politically helpful narrative for both Labour and the Tories (which I think explains the lack of challenge) but deeply problematic for the least well off as it makes genuinely helpful policy that offers people a decent level of support a harder sell.

Ready for more?